One of our posts drew more than 800,000 views and 778 replies because it showed a $500,000 mortgage at 7.5%. After 36 payments, the borrower still owed $485,071. Of $125,859 paid, 88% went to interest.
The calculation is true, but the complete rent-versus-buy decision includes costs on both sides and a third option that helped build our wealth.
The First Three Years of a Mortgage
That $500,000 loan has a payment near $3,496. In month one, about $3,125 is interest and $371 is principal.
After 36 payments, only $14,929 of principal is gone. Roughly $110,930 went to interest. Early mortgage payments mostly rent money from a bank; equity grows faster later.
Rent also purchases shelter and does not return. The right question is who paid less for comparable housing and what happened to the difference.
The Full Cost of Ownership
On a $500,000 home, add about $5,000 yearly for property taxes, $1,500 to $2,500 for insurance, and a common maintenance estimate of 1% of value, another $5,000. Taxes continue after the loan ends.
That is roughly $1,000-plus each month beyond the mortgage. The early all-in cost approaches $4,500, with only about $371 building equity.
When Renting Wins
At 7.5%, the first month’s interest is $3,125; at 3%, it would be $1,250. Renting also deserves consideration if you may move soon because buying can cost 2% to 5% and selling 6% to 10%.
In markets where purchase prices equal 25 to 30 years of rent, buying may depend on speculative appreciation. If comparable rent is $2,000 and ownership is $4,500, investing the $2,500 monthly difference at an illustrative 7% could grow beyond $430,000 in ten years. That requires actually investing the gap.
When Buying Wins
Our response to the debate was that we bought homes that paid us rent. With house hacking, you live in one part of a property and rent another.
Rental income can cover the $3,125 of interest, taxes, insurance, and maintenance while a tenant’s payment also buys $371 of principal. The mortgage did not change. The property changed from something that only cost us to something that produced income.
That is the payoff: the useful line is not always renting versus buying. It is whether the property pays you or requires you to pay it.
This approach helped two social workers with more than $100,000 of debt build 16 units in under six years. We required the deal to work from the first day rather than depending on appreciation.
Run Your Own Comparison
- Total mortgage, taxes, insurance, maintenance, and transaction costs.
- Find rent for an equivalent home in the same area.
- Calculate what the monthly difference could become if invested for ten years.
- Ask whether a duplex, rentable rooms, or another low-down-payment property could produce income.
Do not compare a current apartment with a much larger house. That is lifestyle inflation disguised as analysis. Use equivalent shelter and conservative estimates.
Renting is not automatically wasteful, and a primary home is not automatically an investment. The correct choice depends on duration, rates, local prices, and what you do with any difference.
Stability still has value that a spreadsheet cannot fully price. A family may reasonably pay more to control the home, remain near schools, or avoid a landlord’s decision. A renter may value mobility enough to accept annual increases. Name those benefits explicitly, then compare their price. The goal is not to prove one side morally superior. It is to make the trade with open eyes.
Run a low, base, and high scenario for repairs, rent increases, investment returns, and selling timing. If one option wins only under perfect assumptions, the conclusion is fragile.